• By: Don MacLean

The Exit Party Review: Why Emily St. John Mandel’s Latest Novel Is Essential Reading

In Exit Party, Emily St. John Mandel imagines competing dystopian futures. 


The first thing to note about Exit Party, Emily St. John Mandel’s new novel, is the year in which it takes place: 2031. That’s a date hardly too far into the future to contemplate. The second is that America has essentially dissolved as a country. What was once the United States is now a collection of separate republics or city-states following a period of war and upheaval. Both of these features of the novel are surely intended, at the very least, to convey a sort of convergence between America’s fractured, violent and polarized present and a close-at-hand, ever more dire future. Indeed, one need not suspend too much disbelief to imagine a time that resembles the world Mandel depicts in Exit Party. In this sense alone, the novel feels like a grim warning. 

Nevertheless, Exit Party is a work of fiction. Mandel has a story to tell, one that, in addition to the more realistic but frightening aspects of our current or near-current political moment, features elements of science fiction. The novel begins with the introduction of two characters, Ari and Gloria. They are friends sharing an apartment in LA after the country’s collapse. Ari has recently been released from prison after a lengthy sentence for the crime of hiring a hit man to murder her cousin. The hit failed, the reader learns, and so the cousin is alive and well. Still, the attempt warranted an eighteen-year sentence. Ari, she informs people she comes to know, is a changed person. The world may have entered a phase of breakdown and chaos as she languished in prison; it may now be a world in which militias and criminal enterprises reign havoc, but Ari has discovered her moral compass. How will she navigate such a dangerously altered world? 

She and Gloria agree to attend a party hosted by Gloria’s friend, Kareem. They live in dark times, but people have still found a reason to celebrate: the city’s curfew has been lifted. People can stay out later than 9 pm. Perhaps this means life in the big city will start to resemble life as they once knew it. There’s hope yet. In most respects, it’s the sort of gathering to which most readers can relate. People drink, talk, and wander from room to room. Two people meet for the first time, sneak into a bedroom, lock the door and have sex.  This is not so strange, perhaps: a city in which people have been forbidden from going out at night is sure to engender a lot of pent-up desire. Other developments, however, most definitely are strange, even inexplicable. People watch Kareem as he enters his own kitchen, only to never see him again. There is no way to exit his place through the kitchen; no door he could have walked through and no window big enough for him to slip through. Accordingly, for him to have left the house, people would have had to see him go. Yet no one saw anything of the sort. Kareem simply vanished –  but how? Where did he go? In time the question becomes: is Kareem still alive? Equally strange is the appearance of individuals who bear a striking resemblance to others at the party, including Gloria. They look nearly identical, in fact. Half of the novel’s premise is thus established. There are the twin mysteries of Kareem’s disappearance and the discovery of a few doppelgängers among the partygoers. How bizarre and discombobulating the world has become. 

Societal breakdown is among Exit Party’s most salient themes, as it is in all of Mandel’s novels. Indeed, she is regarded as one of the premier writers of a type of fiction with this theme at its heart: literary dystopian with a subtle but vital dose of sci-fi, mystery and suspense. The effect is to create a fictional world that, in many respects, either resembles our own or reflects our most potent anxieties, even though there are fantastical elements. In Ari’s America, there was something that resembled a civil war. There are now breakaway states that have formed their own republics or, alternatively, breakaway city-states. The state no longer has a firm grip on power. Violence taking many different forms is increasingly common. In France, the novel’s other setting, there are municipalities that have been abandoned by the state. There is an absence of state services that together serve to keep a space functional and livable. Control of such spaces has been ceded to organized crime. Paris is now covered by a dome, the most obvious allusion in the novel to the role of climate change fuelling social breakdown. The dome is meant to protect those who live inside it from the threats of disease and warming, among all the other hallmarks of environmental collapse. It’s thus become a symbol of the simmering conflict between the haves and the have-nots. For this reason, the dome is a point of severe contestation. Those opposed to its creation and what it represents are prepared to engage in violent sabotage, with consequences that ripple far into the future for Ari and other of the novel’s main characters. 

This is the world Ari, Gloria and others must navigate: dangerous, collapsing, violent and fraught with uncertainty. Friendships in such a world are vital to one’s sanity but are typically tinged with suspicion and thus instability. Ari, for example, enjoys the company of Sebastian, a young art student living in Paris, but does not trust him. He must, she thinks, have an ulterior motive in wanting to get to know her better. Similarly, at one point Nico – another of the novel’s main characters – is speaking with Sebastian about her friendship with Ari. They have had a falling out, she tells him. But all is not lost. A disagreement between them is, with the benefit of hindsight, now the source of an insight, a life lesson. Ari had told Nico that she wasn’t the only person to be traumatized by great loss. Ari, too, had suffered in this way. Nico initially took exception to Ari’s claim before conceding that her old friend had a point. Nico confides in Sebastian. 

I think if you live long enough…

you become a migrant from another

timeline. There’s the world you learn 

to navigate as you enter adulthood

and then the world that slips away from 

you by degrees and after a while there’s 

nothing left of it, but you’re still there. 

Ari’s lament was to do with the collapse of one’s country and the terrible loss one is bound to feel. The awful and destabilizing sense of a world in a state of dissolution is what compels people to move elsewhere, no matter the level of hardship or potential abuse they might have to endure. This is in keeping with how we tend to think of migration. The word ‘migrant’ conjures up images of people leaving or escaping one place in the hope of landing in another more hospitable, more stable, more promising place. Nico’s insight is more strictly to do with aging and the passage of time and how the world can start to seem changed and too foreign to really understand. Yet you must still navigate that world, so long as you’re alive. You don’t have to be forced to move geographically, in other words, to be displaced. From this perspective, there is something almost universal about the experience: at some point in life, if we live long enough, we all become migrants of one sort or another. This strikes me as an idea worth pondering. Alas, Nico’s insight is hers alone and has no bearing on subsequent events. It does not, for example,  help to form a more humane type of politics.  

Quantum entanglement is a branch of physics that is said to have deeply perplexed Albert Einstein. The physics may be breathtakingly complicated, but the reason for Einstein’s apparent befuddlement is easy enough to grasp. Quantum entanglement refers to the notion that subatomic particles can sometimes instantly influence other subatomic particles, no matter how vast the distance between them. Einstein wondered how this possibility could be reconciled with the laws of relativity, particularly the one that states nothing can travel faster than the speed of light. The sci-fi mystery at the heart of Exit Party is rooted in this very conundrum. As to how, it is up to the reader to discover. 

Suffice to say, Mandel imagines a parallel universe with a parallel Earth where much is the same as on our Earth but with some vital differences. America in the world that runs parallel with ours is one big surveillance state. There are obvious echoes of fascist and totalitarian states from the mid-twentieth century, especially. Citizens surveil one another, a sorry fact of life that creates a strain running through all person-to-person relationships. Mutual suspicion is the order of the day. Is my father spying on me? Is my best friend? Those who surveil in this way are part of what is called the ‘Service.’ In this world, working for the Service is seemingly a rewarding career choice. For it is among those institutions whose raison d’être is to sustain society’s ‘harmony.’ Working towards this apparently laudable goal is what allows Ibari, the main character in the novel’s second half, to sleep at night. She ignores the dark underbelly of her chosen profession and of the institution to which she’s devoted so much of her life. “How hard you must work not to notice the obvious,…” she acknowledges at one point. The obvious to which she alludes is the pain, suffering, and injustice for which the Service is responsible. People in this world are arbitrarily kidnapped and taken to labour camps. The kids of those taken in this way are raised in orphanages. 

This is the point in the novel where Mandel most explicitly merges the sci-fi and the dystopian with a view towards suspense. Ibari’s America is a fascist state with a frightening grip on the lives of all its citizens. Resistance, to quote a famous line from Star Trek, is futile. Yet Ibari chooses to resist and subvert. She will put herself at great risk in order to keep a promise to protect two young children. The stage is thus set for a potentially edge-of-your-seat showdown. Alas, the tension never seems to be ratcheted up, despite the nature of the world Ibari inhabits and the choices she must make. The reader roots for Ibari, needless to say, but we never fully inhabit her internal dilemma. Her burden never feels as onerous and potentially fatal as it seemingly should. The overwhelming power of the state she is confronted with seems more like an abstract notion than a terrifying and intimate reality. The result is what feels like a squandered opportunity: the expectation of suspense Mandel initially cultivates is, in the end, not realized.

Exit Party succeeds more as a story of our possible dystopian futures. The possibility of parallel worlds is certainly the heady stuff of science fiction. Otherwise, the worlds Mandel imagines seem deeply rooted in our emergent realities. Although hardly exclusively, this is certainly true of America, the setting for much of the novel. Indeed, the distinctive elements of the novel’s competing dystopias – breakdown in one America, mass surveillance in the other – are both increasingly pernicious features of the current moment. The country is so polarized and fractured politically that many commentators suggest it is already in the midst of a civil war. Surveillance via technology is a growing threat to personal autonomy and freedom. The ICE thugs roaming various American cities and detaining mostly black and brown people and sometimes killing unarmed protesters bear a striking resemblance to those almost featureless characters in Exit Party who drive around neighbourhoods in dark vans, searching for those thought to pose a threat to the existing social order. In real-world America and Mandel’s fictional America, those detained in this way are imprisoned either in jails or labour camps. Legal rights are either a fiction or a nuisance, easily dispensed with or simply ignored. Or take the threat of environmental catastrophe that looms over the world in Mandel’s novel. The existence of a dome over Paris meant to protect those inside at the expense of those who live outside feels like a nod to our real-world predilection for technological fixes to the more fundamental challenge of restoring the planet’s health and creating a fairer and more just world. This too seems prescient even if far-fetched. Whatever Exit Party’s flaws, Mandel has her finger on the pulse.