• Sharma Law – Best for a small, founder-led practice on Main Street South, where you can deal directly with the lawyer handling your case.
• Avanessy Giordano LLP – Best overall personal injury lawyer in Newmarket, with personalized client attention and a broad range of injury claims.
• BPC Personal Injury Law Firm – Best for dedicated case-manager support, with offices in Newmarket, Bradford, and Woodbridge.
• All three have physical Newmarket offices and advertise free initial consultations. The right fit depends on your injury and preferred case management.
• As of September 2026, verify licensing with the Law Society of Ontario and confirm fees and terms in writing.
Avanessy Giordano LLP is the best overall personal injury lawyer in Newmarket, running a deliberately conservative caseload that gives each client’s file more direct attention from the lawyer handling it. The firm backs that model with a 4.9-star rating across 179 Google reviews and BBB accreditation since 2023, plus a broader range of listed injury practice areas than either firm compared here.
A serious collision on Highway 404 or a fall in a local store can leave you juggling medical appointments, lost income, and insurance paperwork at once, and finding a personal injury lawyer Newmarket residents can actually meet with in person matters, because legal deadlines start running early and evidence gets harder to gather over time.
None of the three firms reviewed or signed off on this comparison before publication; everything here comes from public records and independent review platforms, and it’s meant as background rather than legal advice for your specific claim.
Each firm takes a different approach to personal injury work, from direct access to the founding lawyer to dedicated case-manager support and a stronger focus on serious injury and disability claims. The table below compares their key services, Newmarket locations, and notable features to help you see how their approaches differ.
| Firm | Best For | Personal Injury Focus | Newmarket Office / Service Area | Notable Features |
| Avanessy Giordano LLP | Personal injury lawyer | Injury and disability focus, with limited other services. | 17075 Leslie Street; Toronto head office; Oshawa office. | Published trial experience; stated no-expense-unless-recovery terms. |
| Sharma Law | One-on-one contact with the founding lawyer. | Injury law plus criminal and regulatory work. | 205 Main Street South; Woodbridge office; serves York Region and beyond. | Accident benefits and brain injury emphasis (self-reported). |
| BPC Personal Injury Law Firm | Case-manager support across several offices. | Injury-only practice areas. | 1065 Davis Drive; Bradford and Woodbridge offices. | 24/7 line; home and hospital visits. |
Avanessy Giordano LLP was founded by Michael Giordano and Aline Avanessy and identifies itself as an injury firm since 2015. Its head office is on Finch Avenue West in Toronto, and it lists a Newmarket office at 17075 Leslie Street, Unit 8, plus an Oshawa location
For readers comparing local options, the firm’s page for anyone needing a personal injury lawyer in Newmarket describes its injury practice and states that meetings can happen in person, at home, in hospital, or online. The firm also lists real estate and employment law as secondary services.
Avanessy Giordano LLP handles motor vehicle accidents, brain injuries and concussions, spinal cord injuries, slip-and-fall claims, product liability, and dog bites. It also takes on long-term disability denials, medical malpractice, and wrongful death.
The firm says it maintains a conservative file load and works with specialists such as surgeons, psychologists, psychiatrists, and physiatrists. First consultations are free. Its Newmarket page states that clients pay no legal fees or case expenses unless compensation is recovered, subject to the signed retainer.
The firm states that both founders practised injury law for more than a decade, mostly at larger firms, before starting their own. Giordano’s biography lists lead-counsel jury and judge-alone trials in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice and accident benefits hearings at the Licence Appeal Tribunal.
Attorney at Law Magazine confirms Giordano received the Ontario Trial Lawyers Association’s Martin Wunder, Q.C. Outstanding New Lawyer Award in 2017, along with the OTLA Distinguished Service Award in 2023.
The Better Business Bureau lists Avanessy Giordano LLP as an accredited business since February 28, 2023, with an A+ BBB rating. BBB notes that accreditation reflects a commitment to its Standards for Trust and is not an assessment of legal skill. On Google, the firm’s profile currently shows a 4.9-star rating on Google with 179 reviews:
“I highly recommend Avanessy Giordano LLP, especially Zoe Meditskos, Janine, and Michael Giordano. From my very first inquiry, their entire team went above and beyond to provide an exceptional client experience.”- Paulina Luviano, 5⭐on Google (a month ago)
Strengths:
• Local Newmarket office backed by a larger Toronto team
• Documented trial and tribunal work at the partner level
• Handles disability, malpractice, and wrongful death claims as well as accidents
Considerations:
• Head office is in Toronto, so ask who will meet you in Newmarket
• Offers some services outside injury law
• Case results on its website are self-reported
Avanessy Giordano LLP is recommended for: Clients facing serious injury, wrongful death, or long-term disability claims who want a firm with a published courtroom record and a Newmarket office.
Sharma Law, founded by Vishal Sharma, lists its Newmarket office at 205 Main Street South and a second location on Highway 7 in Woodbridge. According to the firm’s website, it serves Newmarket and several York Region communities, including Aurora, Richmond Hill, Markham, King City, Vaughan, and Barrie, and accepts clients from other parts of Ontario.
Personal injury is one of the firm’s three listed practice areas, alongside criminal defence and regulatory offences. This broader practice mix may be relevant when comparing firms based on their primary areas of legal work.
The firm’s injury page covers accident benefits, catastrophic impairment, and brain, spinal cord and orthopaedic injuries, as well as wrongful death. It names car crashes, workplace accidents and slips and falls as typical causes.
A profile Sharma submitted to the Toronto ABI Network’s lawyer database reports that most of his time goes to accident benefit claims and brain injury files. Treat that as the lawyer’s own description of his caseload.
Sharma Law says clients deal with the lawyer directly. Client testimonials published on its site describe responsiveness by text, phone, and email, and personal contact rather than hand-offs to an assistant. Initial consultations are free.
The firm states that Sharma completed his LLB at the University of Leicester in 2011 and was called to the Ontario bar in 2014. His biography lists appearances before the Superior Court of Justice and the Licence Appeal Tribunal, which hears disputes over the accident benefits Ontario drivers can claim from their own insurer after a crash.
The team includes a second lawyer, a paralegal and experienced clerks. The firm reports recovering millions of dollars in compensation, which is a self-reported figure.
Sharma Law has a 4.9/5 rating from 252 reviews on Google. The profile also includes:
“Criticized the firm’s professionalism and communication, particularly the experience with email responses.” – VQ, 1⭐ on Google (approximately 11 months ago)
Strengths:
• Founder personally involved in client files
• Self-reported emphasis on accident benefits and brain injury claims
• Downtown Newmarket location
Considerations:
• Shares its practice with criminal and regulatory law
• Smaller team, so ask about workload and coverage
• No fee structure published online
• Little independent review data
Sharma Law is recommended for: Clients with accident benefits or brain injury claims who want steady, direct contact with the lawyer on their file.
BPC Personal Injury Law Firm lists its Newmarket office at 1065 Davis Drive, Unit 7A, with further offices in Bradford and Woodbridge. The website describes BPC as part of the Barapp Law Alliance, and most reviews it displays refer to Barapp Law Firm.
All practice areas shown on its site are injury-related.
BPC covers car, motorcycle, pedestrian, and public transit accidents, slip and fall claims, and dog bites. It also lists orthopaedic injuries and traumatic brain and spinal cord injuries.
The firm advertises free case reviews, a 24/7 phone line and visits at home or in hospital. According to its website, every client is assigned a case manager who coordinates the file and liaises with the lawyer. BPC also says it brings in medical experts, accident reconstruction specialists, and economists to support claims.
BPC states that clients pay no fee unless the case is won. Its homepage does not say how case expenses are handled if a claim fails, so ask.
The team page lists twelve lawyers. BPC says it has helped more than 15,000 clients and highlights several seven-figure outcomes, all self-reported, and past results never predict a new case.
BPC’s site shows a Google rating widget at 4.6 along with a review feed. Reviewers often name individual lawyers and staff, and some note that their claims took several years to settle. Because the reviews carry the Barapp name, it is unclear how many relate to the Newmarket office specifically.
Strengths:
• Injury-only practice with a larger group of lawyers
• Offices in Newmarket, Bradford, and Woodbridge
• Case managers, a 24/7 line and home or hospital visits
Considerations:
• Ask which lawyer and which office will run your file
• Phrases like “maximum” settlements are advertising, not a promise
• Confirm how disbursements work if the claim is unsuccessful
BPC Law Firm is recommended for: Clients who want a larger injury team, a case manager as a point of contact, and offices spread across the York Region and South Simcoe.
The three firms differ in how they structure their personal injury practices, where they operate, and how clients interact with their teams. Some maintain broader legal practices, while others focus primarily or exclusively on injury claims. The table below highlights their practice areas, local presence, experience, client-service approach, and available review evidence to make the differences easier to compare.
| Factor | Avanessy Giordano LLP | Sharma Law | BPC |
|---|---|---|---|
| Personal injury focus | Injury and disability, plus secondary services | One of three practice areas | Injury only |
| Relevant practice areas | Vehicle, brain and spinal, LTD, malpractice, wrongful death, product liability | Accident benefits, brain, spinal, orthopaedic, wrongful death | Vehicle, transit, slip and fall, dog bite, brain and spinal |
| Newmarket/York Region presence | Office on Leslie Street; Toronto head office | Main office on Main Street South | Office on Davis Drive; Bradford and Woodbridge |
| Experience | Founders report 10+ years each; firm since 2015 | Founder called to the bar in 2014 | Twelve lawyers listed |
| Client-service approach | Conservative file load; in-person, home, hospital or virtual meetings | Direct founder contact | Case manager, 24/7 line, home and hospital visits |
| Review evidence | BBB accredited; directory ratings vary | Mostly first-party testimonials | On-site Google widget (4.6), Barapp-branded |
| Other notable features | OTLA-recognized founding partner | Criminal and regulatory practice | Barapp Law Alliance member |
Size is the sharpest contrast. Sharma Law is a compact practice, BPC is part of a larger network, and Avanessy Giordano LLP falls in between, with more weight on litigation and disability claims.
Start with your injury, then find the firm whose experience matches it. A contested catastrophic impairment claim needs different skills than a straightforward soft-tissue claim or a denied disability benefit.
Use these questions in every consultation:
• Is the lawyer licensed? Check good standing through the Law Society of Ontario’s public directory.
• Who handles the file? Get the name of the lawyer and the office responsible.
• What will it cost? Ontario requires most contingency agreements to use the Law Society’s standard form, and fees cannot exceed what the client recovers under Ontario Regulation 563/20. Ask about disbursements too.
• How will you stay informed? Agree on update frequency and preferred contact method.
• Will the firm go to trial? Ask how often it litigates when offers are too low.
• Can you meet easily? Consider office location, home or hospital visits and virtual options.
A personal injury lawyer pursues compensation for people hurt through someone else’s negligence. Typical cases include car, motorcycle, and pedestrian accidents, slips and falls, dog bites, and brain or spinal cord injuries, and some firms also handle long-term disability and medical malpractice.
Many injury lawyers charge a contingency fee, which is a percentage of any recovery. Percentages vary, so ask each firm for its rate, how disbursements are handled, and what you owe if the case does not succeed.
Yes. The Limitations Act, 2002 sets a basic two-year limitation period, generally counted from when the claim is discovered. Shorter notice periods can apply to some claims, including those involving municipalities or accident benefits, so seek advice early.
Avanessy Giordano LLP runs a deliberately conservative caseload, so each client gets closer attention from the lawyer handling their file rather than a case worker. The firm is BBB-accredited with an A+ rating and holds a 4.9-star rating across 179 Google reviews, and clients pay no legal fees or case expenses unless compensation is recovered.
Yes, the firm’s practice covers long-term disability denials, medical malpractice, and wrongful death alongside standard accident claims, which is a broader range than either Sharma Law or BPC lists. Founding partner Michael Giordano has lead-counsel trial experience in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, backed by two OTLA peer-reviewed awards.
Avanessy Giordano LLP stands out as the best overall personal injury lawyer in Newmarket, combining a conservative caseload, a broad range of injury practice areas, and a 4.9-star rating across 179 reviews that neither competitor matches. Sharma Law is worth a look if direct, one-on-one contact with the founding lawyer outweighs everything else, and BPC suits anyone who wants a larger team and dedicated case-manager support across more office locations.
When comparing them, consider the type and severity of your injury, experience with similar cases, location and meeting options, communication preferences, fee and disbursement terms, and whether your case may require litigation. Speaking with two or three firms, asking the same questions, and reviewing the retainer terms in writing can help you compare your options.
This article provides general information and is not legal advice.
