Ward 5 Could Be the Surprise of Ottawa’s Municipal Election
Ottawa’s municipal election is shaping up to be a largely status quo affair. Incumbents have the advantage, there is little indication of a major political shift at City Hall, and much of the campaign has been relatively predictable.
But one ward is attracting an unusual amount of attention.
Ward 5, West Carleton–March, is emerging as one of the more interesting contests in the city, where incumbent Councillor Clarke Kelly faces a challenge from local business leader and healthcare professional Christine Harrison, along with a third candidate, Dylan Nosé.
What makes this race noteworthy is not simply the candidates, but the political circumstances surrounding it.
Kelly was elected in 2022 with 2,549 votes, or 27.39 per cent of valid ballots cast, defeating his closest opponent by just 242 votes in a seven-candidate race. It was a legitimate victory, but hardly an overwhelming mandate.
Since then, Kelly’s term has not been without controversy.
In 2024, Ottawa’s integrity commissioner, Karen Shepherd, investigated complaints arising from an incident involving staff at the West Carleton Kids Korner Daycare. The commissioner found that Kelly had breached Section 4 (General Integrity) and Section 7 (Discrimination and Harassment) of Ottawa’s Code of Conduct. City Council subsequently approved a formal reprimand.
These are significant findings against an elected official, particularly one whose job depends on building trust and maintaining productive relationships with residents, community organizations and city staff.
They do not, by themselves, determine whether Kelly deserves re-election. Voters will also judge his work on local issues, including his advocacy for rural priorities and his role in advancing Ottawa’s 2024 Rural Summit. But the integrity commissioner’s findings are part of the record he must defend.
What is perhaps more politically revealing is the unusual coalition of support surrounding his challenger.
Former Ward 5 Councillor Eli El-Chantiry, who represented the area for 19 years, has endorsed Harrison, as has former Ottawa Police Chief and Senator Vern White. Sitting Kanata MP Jenna Sudds has also publicly supported Harrison, an unusual intervention by a federal politician in a municipal ward contest. A large group of local residents has also publicly rallied behind her candidacy.
El-Chantiry’s involvement is especially interesting. Few people know the political landscape of West Carleton–March better than he does, and his endorsement of a challenger to the incumbent is noteworthy.
Of course, endorsements do not win elections. Too much establishment support can sometimes work against a candidate, particularly in a rural ward where independence is valued.
Still, it is worth asking why this particular contest has attracted so much attention.
Harrison, an entrepreneur and registered psychotherapist who founded Focus Forward Health, brings experience in business, healthcare and community engagement. Her campaign has emphasized rural infrastructure, emergency preparedness and stronger representation at City Hall. Whether that professional background translates into effective municipal leadership remains to be seen.
Kelly, meanwhile, has the advantage of incumbency and four years of experience on council. The third candidate, Dylan Nosé, whose campaign has focused on infrastructure and road safety, adds another dimension to the contest.
West Carleton–March is a large, predominantly rural ward with priorities that can differ considerably from those of urban Ottawa. Roads, infrastructure, development, emergency services and the preservation of rural communities matter deeply to residents. They need a councillor who can navigate City Hall while ensuring their concerns are heard.
That, ultimately, is what this election should be about: effective representation.
There is a tendency in municipal politics to underestimate the importance of individual ward contests. Yet the composition of council, and the ability of councillors to work constructively with one another, often determines whether the city can make progress on issues that affect residents every day.
Kelly could retain his seat. Incumbency matters, and a divided field four years ago does not necessarily tell us how voters will respond in a three-way race today.
But when a councillor elected by such a narrow margin faces a documented Code of Conduct controversy, public opposition from some residents and an unusually prominent collection of political endorsements for a challenger, the contest deserves attention.
Most of Ottawa may vote for continuity on October 26.
West Carleton–March could be the exception.
Header image: (left to right) West Carleton–March Council candidates Brian Nosé, Christine Harrison, and incumbent Councillor Clarke Kelly, who is seeking reelection.



